A COLLECTION OF RECENT ENGLISH-LANGUAGE PSYCHOTHERAPY BOOK REVIEWS
Complied under the direction of Jacqueline A. Carleton Ph.D. for the IJP (Nov 2013).
Brandt, A. (2013). 8 Keys to Eliminating
Passive-Aggressiveness.
Bulik, C.M. (2012). The Woman in the Mirror: How to Stop Confusing What You Look Like With Who You
Are.
Cain, S. (2013). Quiet:
The Power of Introverts in a World That Can’t Stop Talking.
Castonguay, L.G. &
Hill, C.E. (2012). Transformation in Psychotherapy: Corrective Experiences
Across Cognitive Behavioral, Humanistic, and Psychodynamic Approaches.
Deida, D. (1997). The Way of the Superior
Man: A Spiritual Guide to Mastering the Challenges of Women, Work, and Sexual
Desire.
Deida, D. (2005). Dear
Lover: A Woman’s Guide to Men, Sex, and Love’s Deepest Bliss.
Denborough, D. (2014). Retelling the Stories of Our Lives: Everyday Narrative Therapy to Draw
Inspiration and Transform Experience.
Dweck, C.S. (2006). Mindset: The New Psychology of Success.
Firestone, R., Firestone,
L. & Catlett, J. (2013). The Self Under Siege: A Therapeutic Model for Differentiation.
Grawe, K. (2004). Psychological Therapy.
Grawe, K. (2007). Neuropsychotherapy: How
the Neurosciences Inform Effective Psychotherapy.
Herman, A. (2011). The Body Electric.
Lehmann, E. (2012). Resilient-You: Bending With Strong Winds.
Marks-Tarlow, T. (2008). Psyche’s
Veil.
Marks-Tarlow, T. (2012). Mirrors of the Mind: The Psychotherapist as Artist.
Maroda, K.J. (2004). The
Power of Counter-transference: Innovations in Analytic Technique.
McMain, S. & Wiebe, C.
(2013). Psychotherapy Essentials To Go: Dialectic Behavior Therapy for Emotion
Dysregulation.
Schmidt, J.S. (2013). Longing for the Blessing: Midrashic Voices from Toldot.
Shaw, D. (2014). Traumatic Narcissism: Relational Systems of Subjugation.
Tweedy, R. (2012). The God
of the Left Hemisphere: Blake, Bolte Taylor, and the Myth of Creation.
Wachtel, P.L. (2011). Inside the Session: What Really Happens in Psychotherapy.
Brandt, Andrea (2013). 8 Keys to Eliminating
Passive-Aggressiveness.
Reviewed
by: Joshua D. Wright, Hunter College of The City University of New York
Passive-aggressive behavior is more
common than most think and there are likely many times that people act in a
passive-aggressive way without the realization of doing so. This behavior can
be destructive to relationships and can carry over from one relationship to the
next, while hurting loved ones and the perpetrator. Andrea Brandt strives to
address this concern in
8 Keys to Eliminating Passive-Aggressiveness by guiding
readers through practical steps to dealing with anger in a proactive way and
eliminating passive-aggressive behavior.
Written for a general audience
of those who either have identified their own passive-aggressive behavior, or
who may be involved in passive-aggressive relationships, Brandt has created a
fluid narrative using expertly drafted anecdotes taken from her clinical
experience and practical exercises to illuminate concepts. As a
psychotherapist, it is no surprise that Brandt describes the origins of
passive-aggressive behavior as a suppression of anger due to societal
constraints, and an outwardly passive response to situations due to perceived
anxiety to express that anger openly. The eight keys illuminated throughout the
book have the goal of revealing hidden anger, teaching the use of body
sensation to understand and express true emotion, teaching assertive
communication, and guiding people to productive conflict negotiation. According
to Brandt, all of this may require "the healing of childhood wounds" (Intro,
xxx).
The key strength of this book
is the anecdotal stories that line the pages. Each of the eight keys to
reducing passive-aggressive behavior is elaborated through its own dedicated
chapter and each begins with an anecdotal story to demystify passive-aggression
and reflect its various manifestations. Furthermore, each of the primary
chapters contains practical exercises that could be used at home or integrated
into a comprehensive therapy program. In Chapter 1, Brandt introduces the use
of a journal to aid in understanding thoughts, feelings, and actions in
situations with the goal of understanding anger. In Chapters 2 and 3, one can
use checklists to help identify irrational beliefs and unmet needs
respectively. Chapter 4 uses brainstorming techniques, while Chapter 5 has the
reader practice forming assertive statements in the context of specific
situations. Similarly, the remaining chapters contain useful exercises that do
not require any prerequisite knowledge in order to participate. The chapters
inevitably end with the completion of the introductory anecdote to illustrate
how the practical changes and exercises learned could potentially work in one’s
own life. The accessibility of this style lends to a light reading that is
informative without going into unnecessary detail about underlying theory and
research. Furthermore, it allows the reader to jump to sections and exercises
that are relevant rather than requiring a through-and-through reading.
For some, the lack of research
and citations may turn them away but if one takes this book for its intended
purpose, there is something to gain from perusing its pages. General readers
will gain intimate knowledge of their own behavior and suggestions for
eliminating passive-aggressiveness. Likewise, practicing psychotherapists will
be exposed to relevant exercises that can be immediately incorporated in the
clinical setting. This is a hands-on guide, not a research manuscript.
The final chapter reconnects to the
introduction, elaborating on the initial example of passive-aggressiveness and
providing a glimpse into how using the eight keys detailed within the text might
change a previous relationship for the better and thus the book guides readers
through the life of Sarah and Tom as they learn how to negotiate conflict
without the destruction of passive-aggressiveness. Ultimately the path, Brandt
elucidates "[is not] a succession of doors, rooms you can pass through toward
some magical destination" (p. 180). Instead she states, "you’ll be moving back and forth among the keys and eventually realize adjusted relationships with more
enabled responses and less reliance on passive-aggression" (p. 180).
Brandt, Andrea (2013). 8 Keys to Eliminating
Passive-Aggressiveness. New York, NY: W.W. Norton & Company, Inc.
ISBN: 978-0-393-70846-2
Paperback: 184 pages, Index included.
Keywords: Passive-Aggression,
Relationships, Anger, Communication, Assertiveness
Bulik, Cynthia M. (2012). The Woman in the Mirror: How to Stop Confusing What You Look Like With Who You Are. Reviewed by: Nataliya Rubinchik, Hunter College
To be a woman means to fight for life. Women spend their lives fighting against what they see in the mirror and are rarely satisfied. Women have been valued for their appearance throughout history, and despite how far society has come; men still outnumber women in political positions, women are still paid less than men for the same jobs, and equality is still somewhere far in the horizon. Young girls are taught that they are weaker and that the boy should win. Girls are taught to stay quiet and that is what leads them as women to have such low self and body esteem.
Precisely for these reasons, Dr Cynthia Bulik wrote The Woman in the Mirror: How to Stop Confusing What You Look Like With Who You Are. Dr Bulik’s goal is to teach women to be able to separate self-esteem from body esteem. Self-esteem is how we feel about ourselves as a whole; body esteem is just a small part of self-esteem, how we feel about our physical appearance. Many women feel discouraged, put down, and silenced but instead of changing who they are and being heard, they change how they look. They gain a minor victory, but the end result will never be in their favor unless they learn to change what needs to be changed, not settle for what is easy to change. Dr Bulik’s book is a great tool for learning how to get rid of the little voice in your head that never stops criticizing.
The book is divided into two parts û the first part talks about how women are taught to feel about themselves from ‘elementary school to the nursing home’ and the second part gives exercises and tools to readers to challenge what they have been taught and learn to chip away that criticizing voice. For the first few years of their lives, girls fantasize about being princesses; they learn from what they see on TV, in magazines, their dolls. The very first time a girl compares what she looks like to what she sees, her fantasy is over and reality sets in. From then on, her life will be full of self-criticism about her weight, her hair, her skin, her posture, etcetera. And as soon as she starts school and the bullies and popular kids are introduced, self-esteem and body esteem both can begin to plummet. This struggle with how one looks can last for life.
Dr Bulik includes case studies and examples to help her readers understand that almost every woman in the world experiences what her readers do, almost regardless of circumstance. One of the first examples is about the Crown Princess of Sweden who suffered from anorexia nervosa. If a real princess isn’t happy with herself, what is to stop any woman from not being happy with herself?
The intervention methods Dr Bulik includes can be helpful to women of any age willing to try to change how they see themselves. Throughout the book are exercises for the reader to try with examples to show the reader what to do. Every chapter begins with a quote that women of all ages can relate to and find inspiration or sympathy with. Dr Bulik also includes a chapter on how to shelter future generations, which answers questions mothers might have about how to help their daughters not succumb to the pressures of society. This book is clear and easy-to-follow. It is written in a way to combine the experiences of Dr Bulik - a woman, a psychologist and a mother - in a way that can help improve self-esteem and the body esteem of all women.
Bulik, Cynthia M. (2012). The Woman in the Mirror: How to Stop Confusing What You Look Like With Who You Are.
New York, NY: Walker Publishing Company, Inc.
ISBN: 978-0-8027-1999-7.
Paperback: 262 pages.
Does not include bibliographical references.
Key words: eating disorders, self-esteem, body esteem, women
Cain, Susan. (2013). Quiet: The Power of
Introverts in a World That Can’t Stop Talking.
Reviewed by: Jazmine Russell, New York
University.
Susan Cain admits herself to be an
introvert ‘in a world that can’t stop talking.’ Like many of us, she isn’t fond
of working in a busy group setting and shakes with nervousness when asked to
give a public speech. Ironically, my first introduction to Susan Cain was in
her TED Talk about introversion, the very topic of her book, Quiet: The Power
of Introverts in a World that Can’t Stop Talking. In this speech, Susan Cain
carries herself gracefully, speaks confidently, and doesn’t show a twinge of
nervous energy. ‘How did this self-proclaimed introvert do it?’ I thought. This
is the very question that lead me to read her book.
In Quiet, Cain opens the discussion by revealing
her personal quest to her readers. Through discussing the topic of introversion
with many people of all cultures, fields and walks of life, Cain’s goal was to
discover why extroversion was typically favored, what shapes these personality
types in the first place, and what introverts really can and do contribute to
our society that extroverts may not. From participating in a Tony Robbins
seminar on ‘unleashing the power within’ to speaking with developmental
scientist, Jerome Kagan about temperament and personality, Cain discovers an
array of findings and shares them with her readers in a concise and clear
manner.
One may assume, with Cain’s confession of her
own personality type, that the book would be rather one-sided. However, while
she makes a very strong argument, Cain also discusses the importance of both
introversion and extroversion. What she fights against, rather, is what seems
to be the current trend of the ‘extrovert ideal,’ meaning the cultural and
societal push to be outgoing, sociable, and charming in all aspects of life.
Partly a product of genetics, and part consumerism, Cain argues that too much
of a push towards extroversion and what she calls ‘The New Groupthink’ can
hinder people from utilizing their own talents in the way that is more
comfortable and pragmatic for them. In schools and business, for example, when
people are forced to brainstorm or collaborate constantly, pushed into ‘team
building’ exercises, it actually reduces productivity and creation. However,
when people are given the space to go work on their own while maintaining
communication and the opportunity to collaborate, everyone’s personality and
work ethic is accounted for and supported.
Cain also shows readers that some of the most
important events in history and many of the most important inventions in
history came from introverted people. Rosa Parks, Isaac Newton, Albert Einstein,
Steven Spielberg, Larry Page, and Stephen Wozniak, to name a few, all
contributed greatly to society but also typically preferred to work alone and
think deeply before initiating projects. In fact, Cain reveals that having a
more quiet personality listening intently, taking suggestions, and thinking
before acting, can actually make you a more effective leader than those who may
prefer to act quickly, speak more often than listen, and push one’s own ideas
above the group.
Though
her book is about personality, as she does speak of this topic in light of
previous research, Cain is mostly referring to cultural ideals. Knowing that
people are far more complex than a single term ‘introvert’ or ‘extrovert, She
unpacks for us the stereotypes we most likely hold for the sociable, loud,
assertive and gregarious type as compared to the shy, imaginative, quiet,
sensitive type. This is to show us, not only that these stereotypes may be
misguided, but how much we can learn and grow from nurturing both personality
types in business, in school, and at home. Above all, Cain’s message is to
perhaps push yourself outside of your comfort zone if it’s for something you
love, as she did, but mostly to situate yourself in the environment you feel
comfortable in and surrounded by the people you feel comfortable with. Quiet,
an elegantly written book, is packed with information for the business person,
parent, teacher, therapist, along with both introverts and extroverts alike.
Cain, Susan. (2013). Quiet: The Power of
Introverts in a World That Can’t Stop Talking.
New York: Broadway Books
Paperback: 352 pages.
IBSN: 978-0-307-35215-6.
Includes index.
Key Words: Personality, Introversion,
Culture, Temperament
Castonguay, Louis G. & Hill, Clara E.
(2012). Transformation in Psychotherapy: Corrective Experiences Across Cognitive
Behavioral, Humanistic, and Psychodynamic Approaches.
Reviewed
by: Nataliya Rubinchik, Hunter College
Corrective experiences occur
when a patient ‘comes to understand or experience affectively an event or
relationship in a different and unexpected way.’ This book was put together
based on a series of conferences at Penn State University. The editors’ goal
for putting this book together was to explain how different approaches affect
corrective experiences and understand the change in a theoretical, empirical,
and clinical ways.
Transformation in Psychotherapy: Corrective
Experiences Across Cognitive Behavioral, Humanistic, and Psychodynamic
Approaches is divided into three sections. The first section defines
corrective experiences and provides background conceptual information about it.
The second section presents empirical studies and investigations regarding corrective
experiences. Both the first and the second section use clinical material to
explain the idea behind incorporating corrective experiences in therapy
sessions and a guide for how to do so. The third section summarizes the
previous two to tie the background of corrective experiences to current uses of
it.
Corrective experiences are
often used in teaching a client that something they are afraid of doing or
feeling is not as scary as they think. The goal is to teach clients how to deal
with their fears and anxieties. By combining cognitive and behavioral methods
into an emotion-centered technique, therapists work with clients to open new
doors of opportunity.
Every chapter is written by a
different author, highlighting his or her research and allowing the author(s)
to explain what he or she knows best. For example, Dr Marvin Goldfried explains
the concept of corrective experience as the client’s ability to interact with
the therapist and with the therapy in a way that produces therapeutic change
without having to specifically resolve earlier conflicts.
Chapters
are also separated based on the approach in the first section to give the
reader necessary background information from all possible approaches. The
second section begins to talk about empirical data, and incorporates all the
information relayed in the first section. Readers are able to follow the
research presented in all cases from having been introduced to different
techniques and approaches in the beginning.
This
book was put together as a tool for both students interested in learning about
clinical psychology and for experienced clinicians wishing to learn how to
better incorporate corrective experiences into their work. Research and case
studies are presented in this book to give explanations and greater
understanding for readers of all levels. Much of the empirical research focuses
on portraying the clients’ perspectives of corrective experiences. Different
examples are provided of how clients change their behaviors and how they
understand the transformations they go through.
The
third section of the book summarizes conclusions made by all the authors who
worked to put together the book. Readers are reminded that every clinician has
his or her own definition of corrective experiences. Therefore the authors of
final chapter decided to break corrective experiences into two types. This
division of corrective experience focuses on both kinds of changes that can
occur in a client, conscious and unconscious. Type 1 are "new or unexpected
thoughts, emotions, sensations, behaviors or feelings about one’s self that
result from the client encountering an event that is different from his or her
frame of reference." In Type 2 corrective experiences, "the client actively does
something different in situations that typically have triggered apprehension
and negative emotion."
Castonguay, Louis G. & Hill, Clara E.
(2012). Transformation in Psychotherapy: Corrective Experiences Across Cognitive
Behavioral, Humanistic, and Psychodynamic Approaches.
American Psychological
Association: Washington, DC
ISBN: 978-1-4338-1159-3.
Paperback: 390 pages.
Includes bibliographical references.
Key words: corrective experiences,
cognitive behavioral approach, emotional approach, psychotherapy
Deida, D. (1997). The Way of the Superior
Man: A Spiritual Guide to Mastering the Challenges of Women, Work, and Sexual
Desire.
Deida, D. (2005). Dear Lover: A Woman’s
Guide to Men, Sex, and Love’s Deepest Bliss.
Both reviewed by: Nataliya Rubinchik, Hunter
College
David Deida has written
several books for men and women who want a fuller romantic life or who struggle
with their current one. While all of his books could be read by both genders, each is written with one or the other as the expected audience. This allows the
other gender to better understand the thoughts of the gender the book is
written for. Deida’s books are also useful for psychotherapists wishing to
advise their clients on how to better their intimate relationships.
"Stop waiting. Feel everything. Love achingly. Give
impeccably. Let go." Deida’s guide for the ‘superior man’ is not only meant for
a heterosexual man with a masculine essence. It can also be relevant for
homosexual men or women with a masculine essence or for a heterosexual woman
with a masculine essence.
A masculine essence is the
desire from the very core to become successful and liberated from all inner and
outer conflicts. A feminine essence is the desire for love and romance above
all else. Deida believes that every individual has an essence. Usually men have
a more masculine essence and women have a more feminine one, but that is not
always the case. For a successful relationship, it must first be understood who
in the couple has a more masculine essence and who a more feminine one. A
relationship where the essences balance out would be considered the most
successful because the couple is complementing one another and allowing room to
grow.
Even if something causes
immense pain inside, Deida insists that a superior man would be able to deal
with the hurt and turn it back into love: open his body and his heart and allow
breath and spirituality to enter and cleanse the negativity and turn feelings
into truly open love. Freeing oneself - as is the deepest desire for a
masculine essence - from sadness, anger and fear - allows for the betterment of
life. When it comes to a career, for example, it is better to accept fear and
live alongside it, taking it into account when making major decisions, than to
ignore it and pretend that everything is as it is meant to be.
The same rules apply to women
and relationships, in Deida’s perspective. Fear of the unknown and doubt in
oneself is always seen by a woman’s acute eye. If she senses an inner conflict
in her man, she might be wary of his behaviors, causing their relationship to
not be able to blossom to its full potential. Fear stops the growth of anything,
therefore acknowledging fear and accepting it, pushing just beyond the boundary
is what allows self-development. ‘Both forms of intercourse, sexual and
worldly, require sensitivity, spontaneity, and a strong connection to deep
truth in order to penetrate chaos and closure in a way that love prevails.
Deida’s advice for the
superior man sounds initially like criticism. He begins each chapter with a
challenge. Sometimes the phrasing of his sentences sounds offensive in order to
get a reaction from the reader, only to teach a lesson at the end. Sometimes
Deida offers an exercise to the reader to allow him to learn more about
himself. The purpose of all these challenges is to explain to the reader the
differences that come about from making a specific decision.
It is all about priority and
purpose, but at the same time, it is about giving your all in every aspect of
life. Deida’s purpose is to share his observations with the reader on how to be
the best man one can be through ridding oneself of fear and instead opening
oneself to new experiences. This in turn will improve all of the reader’s
relationships: familial, romantic, and worldly.
"Dear lover", begins David Deida’s book to guide women to what
he believes is a deeper and truer experience in love. Written in the second
person, Dear Lover takes its reader on an adventure. Every chapter begins with
a short letter from a lover explaining just how much his woman means to him.
Through these letters, Deida expresses to his readers what a man should feel
when he is with a woman. A woman should not settle for any less than the purest
of emotion.
For
Deida, open love can only be achieved through surrender of all defenses and all
predisposed caution. It’s a hard task but being free of the burden of worry and
fear allows a woman to love to the fullest - not just her man, but herself.
When a woman allows herself to be loved, she has more confidence, everything
about her seems to soften and glow. Deida says that it is this light that comes
from deep in her heart, from being filled with love, that shows a woman’s
spiritual sexiness.
Opening her heart and allowing
a man into the deepest parts of herself create a bridge between complete
emotional happiness and pure bodily pleasure. This experience can be either
sexual or not. Pleasure can come from being happy in life, doing favorite
activities, or just opening oneself to experiences and scenery that are usually
lost in the background.
It is not easy to surrender
all defenses that are around the heart, especially if they have been building
up over many years of betrayal and heartache. Deida understands this and so his
mission is to show every woman that she can be loved the way she wants. That
men desire the same love that a woman does, and as long as she allows a man in,
they can rewrite the years of pain into love and happiness.
Both men and women base their
life decisions on fear û fear of the unknown, fear of rejection, fear of
commitment. But letting go of fear is what allows every individual to blossom
to his or her full potential. This is why Deida makes it clear that choosing
life’s path must be done with an open and fearless heart.
Deida explains how an
individual can identify his or her own essence and what it means to have more
of one. One’s childhood can create an abundance of one essence over the other
depending on parents, experiences, and interests. A successful relationship
would only come from a balance of both essences between the man and the women,
like puzzle pieces completing a picture.
The advice Deida gives is not
only useful in having a successful relationship. It also allows for personal
growth and finding happiness in every day. Giving yourself into love can
improve romantic relationship as well as friendships and family matters. It
clears the mind and body to see beauty in all surroundings.
The Way of the Superior Man and Dear Lover are a great read for both men and women, even though reactions
will be different depending on the background of the individual. Both books
capture the reader from the beginning and allow him or her the chance to view
the world from someone else’s eyes. They create a bridge between men and women,
one that would allow both genders to understand the thoughts and actions of the
opposite gender. Both books guide the reader to begin opening him or herself up
to the unknown by offering support and understanding, while also pushing the
boundary just a little bit.
Deida’s writing flows easily,
captivating the reader. While each guide is written primarily for one gender,
every individual reader would benefit from reading Deida’s guides. Second
person point of view allows the reader to jump into the books and feel like
what Deida writes about is directly for him or her. Deida’s writing feels
personal, as if every word he writes is meant ‘for your eyes only.
Deida, D. (1997). The Way of the Superior
Man: A Spiritual Guide to Mastering the Challenges of Women, Work, and Sexual
Desire.
Boulder, CO: Sounds True, Inc.
ISBN: 978-1-59179-257-4.
Paperback: 195 pages.
List of Resources at the end of the book
Keywords: career, sex, relationships,
women, men’s guide
Deida, D. (2005). Dear Lover: A Woman’s
Guide to Men, Sex, and Love’s Deepest Bliss.
Boulder, CO: Sounds True, Inc.
ISBN: 978-1-59179-260-4.
Paperback: 176 pages.
List of Resources at the end of the book
Keywords: love, sex, relationships, woman’s
guide
Denborough, David (2014). Retelling the
Stories of Our Lives: Everyday Narrative Therapy to Draw Inspiration and
Transform Experience.
Reviewed by: Nataliya Rubinchik, Hunter College
Too often we let our experiences and
circumstances define us rather than making them just a small part of what makes
us who we are. David Denborough wrote Retelling the Stories of Our Lives:
Everyday Narrative Therapy to Draw Inspiration and Transformation Experience as
a way for readers to look back at trauma and injustice they have experienced in
their lives and learn to see it in a different light. By including questions,
exercises, and new ideas, Denborough provides readers with an opportunity to
rewrite the meaning of their story.
Denborough
offers an example from his own life to show how specific events are accompanied
by a feeling of pity and depression while a more detailed scenario can give
depth and understanding to these same events. A young boy with asthma, who
could not speak understandably until 4, alone on a mountain ridge paints a
lonely image in our minds. We learn that his father loved his son and felt like
he was on top of the world, and that his mother could always understand her
boy. The young boy never felt alone, and the day he stood by himself at the top
of the mountain ridge, this boy wrote his very first song. Now we understand
that he was never lonely. Quite the opposite, alone on the mountain this boy
felt like ‘a songwriter on top of the world.‘
Negative
events from our lives haunt us and define us unless we choose to rewrite our
story. We have to learn to separate the good of who we are from the bad that
circumstances outside of our control causes us to become. Denborough includes
activities for the reader as well as examples from his cases to clearly show
the reader what he or she should be doing.
Denborough
divides his book into steps to help the reader go through a hopefully
successful narrative therapy while he or she reads through the book. He begins
with identifying who we are and changing our ‘headline’ from the negative that
follows us around to something positive about ourselves. It is important to
then understand that people are not the problem û the problem is the problem û
and externalizing is the first step to overcoming it. It is important to find
the right audience who will be supportive of our journey whether it is an
imaginary friend, someone we are close with, or just the pages of the book. It
is similarly important to decide who is vital to our lives û who are the people
that are part of our ‘teamö? Once we have identified all of these parts of our
lives, we can begin to put them together into a story of our lives; only when
we tell our story this time, it is about who we really are. Only in this way
can we overcome the trauma we have let define us for too long.
Denborough
includes a number of case studies and examples of all the different experiences
people have gone through and how they used specific exercises from narrative
therapy to redefine themselves the way they want to be. At the end of each
chapter there is a section that goes over what the reader learned in that
chapter. This is a good way to enforce the growth readers should be experiencing
as they go through learning to retell the stories of their lives.
Retelling
the Stories of Our Lives: Everyday Narrative Therapy to Draw Inspiration and
Transformation Experience is written in an organized and easy-to-follow way
which makes it easy for readers who wish to learn to retell their stories to
feel comfortable doing the activities. It is written to be a guide for both
individuals and larger groups of people who want to work together and help each
other through this journey. Denborough gives readers a way to overcome trauma
that has held them back for too long and to see themselves in a better light.
Denborough, David (2014). Retelling the
Stories of Our Lives: Everyday Narrative Therapy to Draw Inspiration and
Transform Experience.
New York: W.W. Norton & Co.
ISBN: 978-0-393-70815-8
Paperback: 310 pages.
Includes bibliographical references and
index
Key words: narrative therapy, trauma, guide
Dweck,
Carol. S. (2006). Mindset: The New
Psychology of Success.
Reviewed by: Jazmine
Russell, New York University.
As a lone researcher, it is a difficult task to be able to take your array of findings and create a valuable
theoretical framework to help others understand the complexities of their
mindset and thoughts. It is an entirely different feat to guide the lay person
through your theory and reveal to them exactly the different ways these
findings can affect and change their lives. Within the topic of motivation,
beliefs, and mindsets, this seems incredibly daunting, as one can imagine the
variety of reasons for why people may believe and act the way they do. However,
for Carol Dweck, this is a welcomed challenge, because Dweck now has a ‘growth
mindset,’ the very thing she endorses in her book, Mindset: The New Psychology of Success.
The
concept of the ‘growth mindset’ began with Dweck’s interest in how people cope
with failure and solve tough problems. In her work with school children, she
began to notice that some displayed high levels of eagerness when faced with a
challenge, while others displayed helplessness. These eager children were the
same ones who understood and believed that qualities such as intelligence and
personality were traits one could develop throughout life; that they are not
inborn or fixed qualities. Therefore, they were motivated to try harder and
build their skills and knowledge as a result of this mindset. The ‘growth
mindset’, as Dweck calls it, is important to how much effort people put into
school, their career, and even their relationships, how much passion they have
for learning, and how much they may thrive when faced with many different kinds
of challenges.
Dweck asks us to consider how
we may handle potential shortcomings and challenges in all areas of life, for
the ‘growth mindset’ also changes the very meaning of failure for individuals.
For example, Dweck describes the child who believes their intelligence is a
fixed trait they are stuck with in life. This is the child who may always be “in
danger of being measured by failure” as “it can define them in a permanent way”
(p. 39). One failure at a task might represent to the child their basic inability
to complete the task, and thinking their traits are fixed, it furthermore
represents their inability to become capable. However, if a child believes
these traits can change with effort and growth, “failures may still hurt, but failures don’t define them” (p.
39). The title ‘The New Psychology of
Success’ implies that with a ‘growth mindset’, success becomes possible
because it simply becomes fathomable to those who believe that change is
possible and effort pays. <
Though Dweck, of course,
emphasizes the positive outcomes of the ‘growth mindset’, she never comes off
as judgmental, but rather, understanding of those readers who may relate to the
fixed mindset. She even tells of her own struggles with the mindset and how the
research she’s done has personally affected her, making her book all the more
enjoyable to read. Relaying her research in a forbearing, rich and enthusiastic
way, Dweck even dedicates chapters of the book to advising parents, teachers,
and role models in how to cultivate a growth mindset in their children. These
findings and information do not just apply to the realm of academic success but
also to the world of business and leadership, artistic and athletic talent, or
even success in romantic relationships. Dweck’s book is beautifully written,
expansive, inspiring, and motivating to readers in the field, therapists,
parents, teachers, leaders, and anyone looking to expand their idea of success
and growth.
Dweck,
Carol. S. (2006). Mindset: The New
Psychology of Success.
New York: Random House.
IBSN: 1-4000-6275-6.
Hardcover: 277 pages.
Includes index.
Key
Words: Success, Intelligence, Mindset,
Relationships, Personality
Firestone,
R., Firestone, L., Catlett, J. (2013). The
Self Under Siege: A Therapeutic Model for Differentiation
Reviewed
by: Joshua D. Wright, Hunter College of The City University of New York
In The
Self Under Siege: A Therapeutic Model for Differentiation, Firestone and
colleagues express the existential view that individuals must differentiate
their identity from those around them, and maintain an inclusive world-view.
The problem, according to Firestone et al., is that destructive thought
processes thwart this goal. This text outlines a useful approach to uncovering
these destructive processes in order to differentiate one’s identity and
fulfill the underlying need for a unique self. Relying on philosophy, this book
is dense and best suited for the academically minded, and specifically for
practitioners with a bent for psychoanalytic theory.
The model of differentiation outlined by
Firestone et al. relies on the assumption that in order to lead a successful,
individual, and creative life, a person must differentiate oneself from others.
This involves avoiding the incorporation of others’ attitudes and personal
attacks on one’s developing personality, while focusing on one’s unique
identity. The model posits a dichotomous construct of the self and anti-self,
in which only one may be activated and it is in the best interest of people to "emancipate themselves from imagined connections with parents, to unlearn
destructive aspects of early programming, and to learn to embrace more
life-affirming ways of satisfying needs and pursuing goals" (p. 6).
After
developing parents as the first and foremost environment in a child’s life,
Firestone et al. outline the construct he calls ‘the voice’, an inner stream of
consciousness from the perspective of the parents or others, in which a
negative opinion reigns.
The solution to eliminating this negative
voice, according to Firestone et al., is voice therapy. This method is outlined
in detail, describing the use of dialogue in the second person as the primary
means for patients to come to terms with their negative internalizations. In
this manner, patients engage in dialogue between the self and the anti-self,
allowing for differentiation between the attitudes and thoughts associated with
the two ends of this dichotomy. Five steps in this process are outlined and
numerous examples from clinical sessions are used to demonstrate this process.
Thus the reader is able to follow multiple individuals through the process, laid
out in an easy to follow dialogue format.
Chapters 5 and 6 extend voice therapy to
the context of couples and sexual relationships, elaborating on how this
process can be adapted using dialogue with the significant other in real-time
and from the second person perspective in turn-taking style. Again, this
process is illuminated via a case history. The underlying problem for Firestone
et al. is always oriented in childhood with negative experiences between child
and parents taking the pivotal position. Chapters 7 and 8 detail the authors’
theoretical perspective on how various types of relationships between mothers
and sons, mothers and daughters, fathers and sons, and fathers and daughters
are seen to affect the ability of a person to differentiate his or her
identity.
Of course, no book on psychotherapy could
be complete without alluding to Freud’s death instinct. Firestone et al. state,
“The enemy of differentiation is awareness of death” (p. 24). Chapter 9
explains how mortality salience leads to automatic defense mechanisms, which
ultimately inhibit the ability to develop towards individuation and autonomy.
The core conflict within development is the “choice between contending with
emotional pain or defending against it” (p. 135) and denial leads to “loss of
personal identity, freedom, and autonomy” (p. 135) and it is necessary to rely
on less defense mechanisms in order to promote differentiation, spurring
greater creativity, and making “us more compassionate toward the rest of
humankind who share our fate” (p. 149).
Chapter 10 extends this thesis to the
larger society. In an effort to try to understand groups, intergroup conflict,
prejudice, and racism, Firestone et al. rely on the argument that “Granting
preeminence to the individual rather than to the state or any of its
institutions is logical as well as ethical because systems are merely
abstractions, whereas people are living entities” (p. 156). Ultimately, society’s
projection of negative group characteristics onto other groups is equivalent to
this same process in individuals and it stems from the individual level where
people are not properly differentiating themselves and becoming unique, free,
and creative individuals. The Self Under
Siege concludes with the conception that empowerment of individuals is the
kindling for larger social change, removing negative aspects of society by
focusing efforts inward to self-awareness reminiscent of Maslow’s
self-actualizationùa book of grounded theory for psychotherapists and
existential enlightenment for the academically minded reader trying to
understand something deep in the heart of humanity.
Firestone,
R., Firestone, L., Catlett, J. (2013). The
Self Under Siege: A Therapeutic Model for Differentiation.
New York: Routledge.
ISBN: 9780415520331
Hardcover: 272 pages.
Notes and index included
Keywords: Self, self-concept, identity, voice therapy, differentiation
Grawe, K. (2004). Psychological Therapy.
Reviewed by: Dorothy Luczak, Columbia
University
Within the text of Psychological Therapy, Dr. Klaus Grawe creates a detailed hypothetical
discussion between a practicing therapist, a research psychologist and a
therapy researcher. This imagined conversation is how Grawe chooses to depict
his ideas on the use of psychologically based procedures to promote healing,
instead of ‘a healing that occurs via mental means,’ used in psychotherapy.
While this is certainly a creative approach in presenting the subject, this
text is concerned mainly with accessibility and practicality. While his
formation of the text is literary in conceptualization, this book is, first and
foremost, a scientific and research-heavy work.
Psychological Therapy is
divided into three main sections, or, as Grawe’s translation calls them,
dialogues. The first is focused on how psychotherapy achieves its effects, the
second with the foundations of psychological therapy, and the third, the most
practical of the three, provides a model for psychological therapy. With these
sections, Grawe attempts to bridge the gap between psychology and psychotherapy
using the voices of his characters. Each character also leads one section, so
that the therapy researcher leads the first, the research psychologist follows,
and the practicing therapist ends the discussion. By creating this scene, the
reader is given a more approachable means at understanding a great deal of
facts and figures.
That is not to say that this
text isn’t dealing with data and research. In fact, there are numerous graphs,
images, and outside resources for anyone who desires to investigate deeper.
Grawe states that for the second section alone, ‘I reviewed over 500
publications from different areas of psychology and neurobiology.’ So that
while the construction is similar to that of a literary piece, this is still a
very scientific work. However, the reading is still very dense and requires a
steady focus on the material. Psychological Therapy demands a serious reader
with time and patience to piece apart its meaning.
The third section, titled ‘A
Psychological Model of Therapy,’ provides the practicality of the
psychologically based procedures. Here Grawe outlines how psychotherapy works,
its efficiency, its inconsistencies and how to apply the framework to various
therapies. He then proceeds to build upon the idea of psychological therapy in
practice. In the second part of Section Three, one of Grawe’s characters
presents the reader with an intake assessment sheet, the intake assessment
procedure, and many other practical tools for a practicing therapist. Using the
voice of his hypothetical practicing therapist, not only does Grawe relates to
practicing therapists who may be interested in incorporating psychological
ideas into their practice, but voices some possible concerns with the process.
This text is recommended for
two specific audiences that the author speaks to specifically. The first
audience Grawe that names in his preface are, ‘colleagues of many different
nationalities,’ since the book was first written in German. So that those who
have heard references of Psychological Therapy, may now read the text itself.
áThe second audience that Grawe mentions would be therapists who have completed
their degrees several years ago. It is this audience that can gain the most from the
second section titled ‘Foundations of Psychological Therapy.’ However, anyone
with an interest in using psychologically based procedures in therapy will find
a wealth of information in Psychological Therapy, and a growing readership may
develop in English reading countries like the original German edition did.
Grawe, K. (2004). Psychological Therapy.
Cambridge, MA: Hogrefe & Huber Publishers.
ISBN: 0-88937-217-9.
Hardcover: 639 pp.
Includes bibliographical
references, author index and subject index.
Key words: psychology, therapy,
psychological therapy, psychotherapy, practice, therapeutic relationship
Grawe, K. (2007). Neuropsychotherapy: How the Neurosciences Inform Effective Psychotherapy.
Reviewed by: Dorothy Luczak, Columbia University
In Neuropsychotherapy: How the Neurosciences Inform Effective Psychotherapy, Dr. Klaus Grawe makes a case for the use of neuroscientific findings in effective psychotherapy. He asserts that these findings should not be taken as a replacement for psychotherapy but as an approach to increase efficiency. As a psychotherapist with a growing interest in neuroscience, Grawe’s perspective acts as a bridge for these two fields, and does so with an explanation of the term ‘neuropsychotherapy.’ While a complex process, it essentially is the idea of drawing upon neuroscientific research to inform psychotherapeutic techniques. Grawe proceeds to educate the reader in a crash course on neuroscience and parses its jargon. He provides graphs, figures and various empirical studies to support his claim and suggests implications for psychotherapy. Grawe believes that the neurosciences can maximize the effectiveness of psychotherapy and lead to a positive outcome in clinical practice.
Neuropsychotherapy was published posthumously in 2007, just as neuroscience was beginning to contribute to psychotherapy. Looking back, his ideas were indeed innovative for the time, and helped shape the approach that psychotherapy has in regards to neuroscience today. His fervor for the subject is apparent in the text and in the forwards where peers remark on Grawe’s desire to disseminate his work, especially into an English translation. This desire to communicate to practitioners, researchers and students across the globe is the driving motivation for Neuropsychotherapy’s creation. His first book, Psychological Therapy, is referred to as a ‘shift in emphasis,’ where the focus is rooted in psychology while Neuropsychotherapy is rooted in neuroscience. They are paired as ‘complementary attempts to provide a theoretical foundation for a ‘generic psychotherapy,’’ and while Neuropsychotherapy is accessible as a stand alone work, Psychological Therapy might provide a smoother transition into Grawe’s ideas.
The wealth of information Grawe presents is staggering, not only in terms of visual aids but also in terms of references. In his preface, Grawe states that the data used to fuel this text was collected in only half a year of self study and research. His main concern, however, is to assist with clinical practice, and that is addressed in his fifth chapter ‘Implications for Psychotherapy.’ There Grawe spells out concrete guidelines for using all the information the reader has gleaned from the previous four chapters and how to apply it to practice. He divides this into two sets of guidelines, the first for therapy planning and the second for therapy process. The first set of guidelines is a brief list of ten steps for leading to a treatment plan. These ten steps are analytical and explicitly organized. The second set is also a list of twelve steps that guide what the practitioner should be considering while attempting to process the session in relation to neuroscientific research. These steps are lengthier and more descriptive in style. These guidelines will be of interest to currently practicing therapists.
Neuropsychotherapy is a helpful tool for therapists attempting to understand the purpose and perspective that neuroscience provides. There is also merit in using Grawe’s work as a supplement to a student’s coursework in psychology and neuroscience. The text sits at a critical point in time and it is a contribution to the merging of these two fields. By incorporating these two subjects in a detailed, organized and easy to read book filled with visual aids, empirical studies, anecdotes, and guidelines Grawe’s effectively portrays the deeper connection between neuroscience and psychotherapy and the value of that connection.
Grawe, K. (2007). Neuropsychotherapy: How the Neurosciences Inform Effective Psychotherapy.
New York: Psychology Press, Taylor & Francis Group.
ISBN: 9780805861228
Paperback: 476 pp.
Includes bibliographical references, author index, and subject index.
Key words: neuropsychotherapy, neuroscience, psychotherapy, psychology, therapy practice
Herman, Aimee (2011). The Body Electric.
Reviewed by: Nataliya Rubinchik, Hunter
College
"If anything is sacred the human body is sacred" wrote Walt
Whitman in his poem, The Body Electric. Everything is connected "our body, our mind, the sea,
the wind". Interconnectedness exists within us as humans and between us as
beings of this planet. This book, edited by Aimee Herman, puts together a collection
of photographs, stories and poems that depict the connection between being and
feeling and entwining with everything around us. Most of the contributors to
this book are writers and poets and photographers, however a civil engineer, a
basketball point-guard, and a man who works for technical support, also
contributed to this beautiful book.
Most photographs in this book
are those of the naked body. Alone or with another, these images show the most
intimate side of humanity in a beautiful manner. The photographs are all
grayscale, which creates an aura of intrigue, intimacy, and mystery in every
photograph. Some photographs are connected to the story or the poem they are
placed next to and leave an image in our mind for when we begin to read. Others
are there for beauty and to provoke thought.
Salita
S. Bryant is a professor of English, who has a degree in literature, clinical
counseling and poetry. Her poem, Anatomy Lesson: A Poem, was originally
published in the International Body Psychotherapy Journal and then included in
The Body Electric. This poem ‘reviews’ parts of our anatomy by comparing humans
to animals to which we are similar made. Our fingerprints are similar to that
of Koala bears, our burley bone is like a dove’s wing, yet humans are the only
species in the world that can weep. Bryant poetically describes who we are as
humans and what we are capable of by explaining of what we are made up.
Bryant has a way of making the
reader feel very small and alone, but at the same time very strong and typical.
We are all alike, humans and animals, and we are never alone. It is this
ability to make us all relatable that shows Bryant’s talents. Her knowledge of
who we are as humans and her mastery over words add together to make a
beautiful poem.
This book is full of short
stories and poems that depict the beauty and intimacy of being human. As the
reader goes through each piece, deep emotions are awakened and there is a sense
of understanding and belonging and being aware of every part of oneself.
Inspired by Walt Whitman, this collection of photographs, stories, and poems "provides
a contemporary examination of the body".
Herman, Aimee (2011). The Body Electric.
New York: Ars Omnia Press.
ISBN: 978-1484977996.
Paperback: 174 pages.
Does not include bibliographical
references.
Key words: body, photographs, fiction,
poetry
Lehmann, E. (2012). Resilient-You: Bending
With Strong Winds
Reviewed by: Tina R. Lee
Elizabeth Lehmann’s audio CD program Resilient-You introduces a simple approach to regulating stress. A seasoned
psychotherapist, Lehmann takes the listener through eight physical calming
techniques that can be utilized anywhere and at any time. The techniques mainly
focus on breathing and greater awareness of the body. Lehmann names each
technique, such as the first called ‘Wanna hold your hand,’ making it fun and easy to remember.
In ‘Wanna hold your hand’ (a takeoff on the Beatles), the
listener allows his/her dominant hand to hold the non-dominant hand. Lehmann
describes that the non-dominant hand is the place where we feel more
vulnerable. As the listener holds, he/she takes note of the changes that are
happening with the body such as slower breath or a shift in posture. Lehmann
tells listeners to welcome everything that comes even if there are no changes.
The goal is to actively work with the nervous system to bring the body to a
state of natural equilibrium. Other techniques introduced in the CD include:
(1) ‘Every breath you take’ - breath into the nose deeply into the stomach and
slowly out through the mouth; (2) ‘Embrace-able you’ - cross arms over chest
and hug yourself for one or two minutes; (3) ‘Rock steady’ - hold onto a
chair/table and connect with the solidity for one or two minutes; (4) ‘Grounding
yourself’ - a slower and longer experience, in which you are firmly planted
like a tree; (5) ‘Walking on sunshine’ - you stand on your feet, walk around
and notice the contact of each foot with the ground; (6) ‘Feel of your touch’ - one hand is on the chest and area above the stomach while you imagine a golden
light or supporting hand to center yourself; (7) ‘Vocal toning’ - chant the
word ‘voom’ several times letting the sound start in the belly and rising
upwards to the mouth.
Some of the techniques are short and
active while others are meditative. Lehmann advises listeners to repeat the
steps as much as they want. According to Lehmann, the calming techniques prompt
the nervous system to restore a‘resilient-you.’ The theory is based on the
assumption that all individuals have inner and outer resources, which can be
effectively tapped into. Lehmann states that people have an inner wisdom that
knows exactly what is needed; individuals only have to allow themselves to
spontaneously and internally change. However, Lehmann notes that not everyone
has the same response and that what works effectively for one individual may
not be so effective for another. To that end, Lehmann encourages listeners to
experiment with all the techniques and find the ones right for them.
The audio CD has a soothing tone throughout
the program with Lehmann guiding the listener throughout. She exhibits the
necessary flexibility for the listeners to adjust to each new approach. Yet,
she never pressures the listener to use any technique, even encouraging
acceptance of no changes. The section topics are well-organized and easy to follow,
starting with informative facts about the nervous system and ending with
proven-resilience guided experiences. The program can complement any approach
to personal growth and/or development. However, listeners cannot practice the
techniques while driving, etc. as it involves full attention. According to
Lehmann, mindfulness is simply resting in a gentle awareness of thoughts,
feelings, perceptions and/or body sensations as they occur. The program puts
these ideas into action and shows its effectiveness even within moments of
trying the first calming technique.
In particular, there is an interesting
section called ‘Experiencing gratitude’, where Lehmann tells listeners to ask
themselves, "For what, in this very moment, are you grateful?" Once listeners
have thought of it, they should allow themselves to connect more with the
gratitude. Elizabeth calls it the ‘experience of gratitude.’ This part has a
spiritual theme underlying it, and it illustrates how extensive and holistic
the program is.
Lehmann goes on to describe resourcing,
which can be a pleasing memory, person, place, action or personal quality that
calms you. It unconsciously happens all the time, according to Lehmann.
Identifying and consciously working with your resources, as well as developing
new ones, helps you feel more fully centered and alive. Inner resources tend to
be personal qualities we have û inner strengths that help us self-regulate. For
example, your imagination and creativity could be an inner resource while humor
can also be a resource. On the other hand, outer resources can be subjective,
in that it can be whatever is soothing to you such as a creative endeavor or an
emotional support group. Lehmann even states that the right kind of healthcare
such as vitamins may help. There are unlimited possibilities of resources.
Resources may even change over time, which is why it’s important to have a
diverse repertoire of resources to turn to when needed.
Resilient-You puts into practice
common-sense ideas of mindfulness and body psychotherapy. Just the simple
awareness of your feet on the ground can shift your perspective to a more
holistic and centered one. Although Lehmann assures listeners that it’s fine if
there are no effects, even skeptics would have a difficult time to not feel any
changes for any one of the techniques presented. The audio is also a quick and
easy listen, broken down into sections for listeners to go back to. The program
proves to be an invaluable guide for those new to mindfulness or even for those
who are experienced and wish to supplement their collection with an in-depth
resource.
Lehmann, E. (2012). Resilient-You: Bending With Strong Winds.
[Audio CD] CD Baby.
ASIN: B00ARWWQ8U
Also available as an MP3 download.
Marks-Tarlow, Terry (2008). Psyche’s
Veil.
Reviewed
by: Nataliya Rubinchik, Hunter College
This
nonlinear concept is based on chaos theory, complexity theory, and fractal
geometry. Chaos theory revolves around unpredictability and disorder,
exemplified by the ‘Butterfly Effect.’ Complexity theory studies the effects of
one behavior on another and how that might result in self-organization. Fractal
geometry is a set of instructions that is used to find the never-ending
self-similar patterns that eventually begin to resemble chaos. The three ideas
relate to each other almost paradoxically, which brings us back to
Marks-Tarlow. She believes that at our core, every person has a fractal
structure, a self-similar pattern that boxes us in and defines us.
Her way of viewing the world
of psychology revolves around interactions on both a conscious and subconscious
level among the self, the world, and others. She identifies psychological
complexity as coming from self-self relations, self-others relations, and
self-world relations. Fractal thinking on a therapist’s part might allow him or
her to see the bigger issue in interactions and relations he or she sees. One
has to start small and allow the bigger picture to present itself as the
pattern is found. This pattern is replicated over and over and is seen in behavior
and personality. Once the therapist has found it, he or she can trace it back
to the beginning.
Each
chapter focuses on one specific aspect of nonlinear psychotherapy and its
complexities. Marks-Tarlow includes a number of case studies to illustrate her
points, explaining how each concept of nonlinearity applies to the patient and
that individual case. She first tells the story of the patient and then
discusses each element to explain its importance in the case and for treatment.
Marks-Tarlow makes a point of reminding the reader, first and foremost, that
the only thing that is certain is uncertainty. This is what allows a clear mind
going into every individual case and it is what keeps the mind constantly at
work to understand what is happening in each specific case.
Marks-Tarlow
cites background research to support her ideas. If the information she uses
requires further explanation, she condenses it into a small box labeled ‘Science
box.’ The Science box gives further background and explanation, including
relating it to what she’s talking about. This keeps her writing very clear and
straightforward as well as giving the book an organized look. She also includes
numerous pictures, graphs and figures as explanations and as a way to
illustrate her concepts to readers in an understandable way.
Psyche’s
Veil can be understood by professionals in psychology as well as by a more
general reader. However, without some prior knowledge, it may seem complicated
at first and will take some effort to understand all the concepts. The
definitions, explanations and figures that Marks-Tarlow includes help readers
along the way. The book as a whole gives off a feeling of being academic. This
in turns makes it seem appropriate for a both clinicians and academic readers.
Having
a clear outline presented to the reader keeps the book organized and
understandable. Every case study adds personality and explanation to theories
and ideas, allowing the reader to follow the concepts. Marks-Tarlow shares her
experiences with readers to give us the opportunity to view psychotherapy in a
different light that perhaps would be more successful in treatment. Even the
darkest and most chaotic of stories has the possibility to end with self-growth
and organization.
Marks-Tarlow, Terry (2008). Psyche’s Veil.
East Sussex: Routledge.
ISBN: 978-0-415-45545-9.
Paperback: 343
pages
Includes bibliographical references and index
Key words: psychotherapy, chaos,
nonlinear approach, fractals
Marks-Tarlow,
T. (2012). Mirrors of the Mind: The Psychotherapist as Artist.
Reviewed
by: Tina R. Lee, New York University
To
the outside world, psychotherapists are seen as the archetypal tabula rasa, the
blank slate that interprets the inner worlds of others while sharing little of
their own inner workings. Yet a collection of artworks, curated by Terry
Marks-Tarlow and produced by the Los Angeles County Psychological Association
(LACPA), illustrates how this assumption of the therapist cannot be further
from the truth. The collection, titled Mirrors
of the Mind: The Psychotherapist as Artist, displays beautiful artworks by
therapists within various fields.
After
putting out the call for artists and performers, there was a huge response from
the Los Angeles county psychotherapists. The venue consisted of an art gallery,
theater performance and lectures. The art exhibition gave psychotherapists the
opportunity to display their core values through a myriad of paintings,
photographs, drawings, sculptures, videos, and performances.
Artworks
are spread throughout the book alongside photos of the artists, descriptions of
the work as well as the artists’ backgrounds. The theme of this collection lies
in the belief that just as the artist takes the interior and gives it form and
substance so that what was once only known to the artist can now be known by
all, the therapist coaches and encourages clients to give form and substance to
their own interior experiences.
Striking
pieces include Natalia Boucher’s ‘Follow Me’ which is a photograph on metallic
paper depicting two footsteps walking on the beach. It illustrates the
relationship of a father and son. Natalia illustrates how they do not need to
follow each other’s steps exactly, as long as they are together in the journey
to give each other support. A strong believer of the psychological powers of
the ocean, Natalia says that it’s a reminder of the fleeting beauty of life, in
that the footsteps seem to disappear to make way for something new. Another
unique piece is by John LaSalle - a singer, composer, arranger,
psychotherapist, and artist. His wife’s oil paint on canvas, ‘Family,’ is
accompanied by original song lyrics which discusses his lost youth.
As
one artist puts it: through the process of healing and recovery, the self
begins to emerge. It is not a linear process - it is messy and involved but
also vital to the survival of the true inner self. In particular, Elisabeth
Linn’s ‘The Emergent Self’ speaks to the idea of the true self emerging by
breaking through the boxes and constraints we often lock our ‘self’ up in. Mirrors of the Mind is a precious
collection of works reminding us to live our most authentic selves through free
and artistic expression.
Marks-Tarlow,
T. (2012). Mirrors of the Mind: The Psychotherapist as Artist.
Encino, California: LACPA.
ISBN: 978-1-62030-733-5.
Hardback: 101 pages
Key
words: art, artists, photography, self,
theater, drawing
Maroda, K.J. (2004). The Power of
Counter-transference: Innovations in Analytic Technique.
Reviewed by: Nataliya Rubinchik, Hunter
College
Psychotherapy is a two-way
street: as patients lean on their therapists for support, therapists have to
freely offer their support back to the patients. The idea of
counter-transference is that therapists feel the emotion and truly empathize
with their patients as the latter relive highly emotional memories. Dr Karen
Maroda, a psychotherapist in private practice, spent her early career building
a wall between herself and her patients, never quite showing the true extent of
her feelings in response to patients’ experiences. When her patients complained
to her or terminated their sessions, explaining that therapy felt cold and
emotionless, Dr Maroda realized it was time for a change. She began to
incorporate counter-transference in her sessions, against others’ warning, and
quickly found what a difference meeting in the middle makes.
The
Power of Counter-transference: Innovations in Analytic Technique teaches
readers, both students and experienced clinicians, how to lead a, hopefully,
successful psychotherapy session. Dr Maroda begins with advising therapists to
set up a working relationship with the patient from the start. She tells the
reader that, from her experiences, the best relationship between patient and
therapist is one founded on equal ground. Many therapists may be wary of
allowing the patient into the therapist’s own life and therefore try to
maintain power over them by staying authoritative and cold. Taking away the
therapist’s role of being the authority leaves more room for both individuals
to actually grow by learning from one another. In addition, when the therapist
and the patient are on equal ground, the therapist may feel like he or she can
trust in his or her patient, reassuring the patient that he or she can confide
in the therapist. This give and take relationship is the first ingredient to a
successful therapy.
One fear therapists have when it comes
to counter-transference is that patients with a history of pathological
behaviors will try to pass those temptations and behaviors on to their
therapist. This makes it difficult for a therapist to relate to the patient.
Sometimes it even results in the therapist putting space between him or herself
and the patient because of dislike of the patient due to pathological behavior.
Therapists tend to divide individual patients into two parts û the
understanding patient who is trying to change and the pathological patient,
haunting the patient’s other half. This division causes the therapist to battle
with him or herself as they may like half of the patient but don’t like the
other half.
Another
key part of a successful therapy session is understanding the reason behind
patients’ fears. It is rare that patients seek therapy feeling they really do
not wish to change. Many individuals actually seek therapy hoping to change too
much. This puts the responsibility on the therapist’s shoulders to carefully
explain to patients that the goal of therapy is not to change the sort of
person one is, but to teach patients to accept who they are and think
differently about themselves and their surroundings.
Dr
Maroda guides her readers through these challenges, sharing her experiences and
referencing experiences of others. She explains with great detail what kind of
feelings the therapist might feel, what he or she should share with the
patient, and what the therapy sessions should feel like. She explains how
counter-transference would work, how to incorporate it into therapy sessions,
and what the issues or consequences of it might be. Through her experiences, Dr
Maroda is able to reveal the fine details of what she views as a successful
therapy.
Maroda dedicates a chapter to each important aspect of counter-transference and
therapy. She begins with advice for how to create a strong foundation and moves
on to the history of counter-transference, its techniques, and its consequences
during therapy and after therapy is completed. A clear breakdown of chapters
into subsections allows the reader to more easily follow and absorb the
information. At the end of each chapter is a subsection summarizing the most
important points of that chapter. Dr Maroda’s own experiences allow the reader
to feel like they have walked a mile in her shoes by the time they finish
reading The Power of Counter-transference: Innovations in Analytic Technique.
Maroda, K.J. (2004). The Power of
Counter-transference: Innovations in Analytic Technique.
New York, NY: Routledge, Taylor &
Francis Group.
ISBN: 978-0-88163-414-3.
Paperback: 197 pages.
Bibliographical references included.
Key words: psychotherapy, counter-transference,
analytic technique
McMain, S. & Wiebe, C. (2013) Psychotherapy Essentials To Go: Dialectic Behavior Therapy for Emotion
Dysregulation.
Reviewed by: Nataliya Rubinchik, Hunter
College
Psychotherapy Essentials To
Go! Dialectical Behavior Therapy for Emotional Dysregulation is one of a six
part series, each of which includes a DVD with instructions and examples, the
book itself, and a practice reminder card. Each book concentrates on one type
of therapy and pushes the reader - both clinician and student - to learn how to
successfully conduct that therapy. The editors, Paula Ravitz and Robert
Maunder, wrote the introduction to briefly explain why the series was written
and to share with the reader the best way to go about learning the therapy.
They explain that it’s best to start with the DVD instruction, then read the
corresponding text.
This
particular book focuses on Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT). DBT requires
four modes of therapy to be incorporated: skills training, telephone
consultations, individual therapy, and a consultation team. These four
therapies put together will hopefully achieve five functions for clients with
emotional dysregulation: teaching new skills, generalizing new behaviors,
improving motivation, ensuring that the client’s environment encourages change,
and supporting therapists. These five functions, if successful, encourage
patients to change harmful or abnormal behaviors while accepting who they are
at any given moment.
DBT
was created as a mixture of Learning Theory, Zen philosophy, and Dialectical
philosophy: tying together the idea of change and the acceptance of the moment.
Dr Marsha Linehan first developed this therapy when she noticed that patients,
particularly those with Borderline Personality Disorder, would get angry and
drop out of therapy after Cognitive Behavioral Therapy. Dr Linehan saw that the
patients didn’t want to accept change, which is how the idea for a therapy
based on acceptance of self, the moment, and future change came to be. At first
glance, acceptance and change seem like two opposite poles, but through
Dialectical philosophy, Dr Linehan found common ground and a way to incorporate
both into one. The push for change and the acceptance that the present moment
is perfect the way it is create the delicate balance that is DBT.
DBT
includes 12 different strategies that can either be used alone or together,
with one another as well as with other therapies. Shelley McMain and Carmen
Wiebe focus on four of these strategies in their book - validation, commitment
strategies, behavioral chain analysis, and skills training.
Validation conveys the
understanding of the client’s experiences, building a foundation for trust
between clinician and client. Commitment strategies are designed to give
clients a feel of safety for them to stay committed to the therapy and the
desired change. Behavioral chain analysis is the method of analyzing the
problem at hand and breaking down what behaviors led up to it. In this way,
both the clinician and the client would be able to think of solutions to that
initial negative behavior. First the clinician works with the client to
identify the specific problem, then to identify vulnerabilities and prompting events.
Next, they work together to identify the links between prompting events and the
behavior and can learn to identify the consequences. Teaching skills is just
one way to deal with the problem identified through behavioral chain analysis.
Each of these strategies is
dedicated a chapter in the book to relay to the reader the most important
points to remember regarding DBT. Through its clear and organized writing, Psychotherapy Essentials To Go: Dialectical Behavior Therapy for Emotional
Dysregulation is a great learning experience as it explains through figures and
points how to lead a successful therapy. The additional information such as the
lesson plan, quiz, reminder card, and DVD only add to the information being
offered to the reader. By following the instructions of the editors, readers
gain insight and knowledge into how best to incorporate DBT into their work and
how best to help clients who require this therapy.
McMain, S. & Wiebe, C. (2013) Psychotherapy Essentials To Go: Dialectic Behavior Therapy for Emotion
Dysregulation.
New York, NY: Norton and Co.
ISBN: 978-0-393-70825-7.
Paperback: 135 pages
Includes bibliographical references.
Key words: dialectical
behavior therapy, emotional dysregulation, psychotherapy, handbook
Schmidt,
J.S. (2013). Longing for the Blessing:
Midrashic Voices from Toldot.
Reviewed
by: Nataliya Rubinchik, Hunter College
Dr Judith Sarah Schmidt, upon turning
seventy, decided to take up the challenge of a Midrash. Dr. Schmidt is a
psychotherapist in private practice with an eclectic background, who has
trained and supervised many cohorts of body psychotherapists, most recently
with the Center for Intentional Living.
A Midrash is an interpretation
of the Torah that fills in the gaps an individual might feel exist in order for
the individual to understand and connect with religion on a deeper level. Dr
Schmidt’s Midrash is on the stories of Isaac, Jacob and his brother Esau,
Sarah, Rebecca, Rachel and Leah. She wrote her Midrash to sound like a modern
story, adding life to characters previously too complicated to even begin to
understand. Dr Schmidt begins with Abraham’s attempted sacrifice of his son,
from Isaac’s point of view. Through her eyes, we gain more sympathy and
understanding for why Abraham was so pushy with Isaac. Perhaps he wanted only
for his son to witness his God.
Dr
Schmidt’s Midrash is only one interpretation of millions, so it is not to be
taken at face value. It’s true value lies under the words, in the readers’
ability to connect with the stories from the Torah and understand them at a
deeper level through one woman’s interpretation of what the characters were
really like. She writes in first person point of view to further bring to life
ancient characters we all know but might not all understand.
She explains decisions made by
each character, as she thinks they were rationalized, in a way that makes sense
to the reader. For example, Jacob’s deception of his father, Isaac, to receive
for his blessing is a complicated event. Dr Schmidt, writing from Isaac’s
perspective, explains that perhaps he knew he was being lied to by his son, but
gave the blessing because this son knew what to do with it. And perhaps Isaac
always knew Jacob was destined for greatness, so giving the younger son his
blessing was always the right thing to do. It is possible that Rebecca, Isaac’s
wife, was not as deceiving as she seemed either, only familiar to the pain of
being the younger twin and longing to keep her younger son from experiencing it
as well.
Dr Schmidt allows the reader
to see into her own mind as she was working on her Midrash. She tells the
readers that the characters would come to her at any moment of the day to personally
tell her their story and to explain their actions. Jacob, the son who always
appeared to be sly and conniving, may have had holier reasons for deceiving his
brother. Esau, the son who gave his all for nothing in return, may have found
love and salvation upon leaving home.
Stories that are taught from
childhood to be unquestionable are questioned and beautifully explained by Dr
Schmidt. She fills in the gaps that may exists in people’s minds about why
Abraham would sacrifice his child, or why Esau would give up his father’s
blessing in return for a bowl of lentils. She shares her experiences with these
biblical characters and presents them to the reader as more human than we are
used to. This makes them more relatable and understandable.
Dr Schmidt shared a little of
her personal ancestry û her great-grandfather, who was attacked by Cossacks
that cut off his beard. His inner conflict between his fearful, frozen heart
and his need for faith and God. The Rabbi’s family took a chance and moved to
America after this attack, beginning anew in the land of opportunity. Dr
Schmidt tells readers that when she turned seventy, she took a trip back to her
hometown of Boibrke, Poland. The aftermath of World War II left the town with
no Jews, desecrated graves, and Polish citizens full of regret for standing by
and doing nothing.
Longing for the Blessing:
Midrashic Voices from Toldot gives readers an experience of a lifetime.
Explaining religious stories in a different light clears up possible questions
and creates a deeper connection between the reader and his or her biblical
ancestors. Sharing her private story connects readers to one another, as her
pain and loss is universal. Reading Dr Schmidt’s Midrash is a unique
experience, which can be appreciated by all people from a religious background.
Schmidt,
J.S. (2013). Longing for the Blessing:
Midrashic Voices from Toldot.
St. Louis, MO: Time Being Books.
ISBN: 978-1-56809-217-1.
Paperback: 84 pages.
Does not include biographical references.
Key
words: Midrash, poetry, Jewish history
Shaw, Daniel (2014). Traumatic Narcissism:
Relational Systems of Subjugation.
Reviewed by: Nataliya Rubinchik, Hunter
College
Dr Daniel Shaw, a clinician in private
practice in New York City, has interacted with a variety of narcissistic
people, beginning with a religious leader whom he used to follow and most
recently with a woman who reached out to him because her parents were both
traumatizing narcissists. Such meetings throughout his adult life were the
reason he decided to pursue how clinicians would be able to help the victims of
traumatizing narcissists.
Dr Shaw describes the way in
which narcissists view the world. They remain consciously ignorant of the fact
that they need others’ attentions but they quickly make themselves
indispensible in others’ lives, ensuring that their victim will always come
back because of dependency. Even though traditionally researchers viewed
victims of traumatic narcissists as pathological as well, Dr Shaw’s goal is to
show that victims are just that û victims who suffer from depression from their
traumatic experiences.
Dr Shaw focuses on
narcissistic parents and the ways in which their adult children might have been
affected throughout their life by their parents’ personalities. This leads to
his assertion that working with narcissistic people is largely intersubjective.
Relationships, both healthy and not healthy, depend on the connection between
two people. When it comes to children, it’s very easy to upset their delicate
development by not maintaining a good relationship based on understanding and
recognition.
Dr Shaw cites an example of
how a child can grow up traumatized if his or her narcissistic parents care
more about themselves and leave the child to take care of both him or herself and the parents. The child is left feeling like he or she cannot depend on the
parents and grows up full of self-loathing. To avoid these situations, there
must be a balance between parents and children, which includes recognition of
children’s accomplishments and love and returning it, important factors of
which narcissistic parents are not capable. Narcissistic parents justify their
inability to show love by blaming the child for being undeserving of it causing
the child to try to become someone he or she isn’t. As adults, children of
narcissistic children still maintain that need to be loved and continue to try
and please everybody, since that is the only way they know to receive
recognition.
Dr Shaw includes case studies to illustrate the idea of
intersubjectivity between narcissistic parents and their traumatized children.
He clearly explains his theories to the reader in a way that is understandable
for experienced clinicians and inexperienced students. The subject of this
book, the victims of traumatizing narcissists, has not been widely studied,
making Dr Shaw’s book a bridge between past knowledge of children, development,
and narcissism and the hope of finding a way to facilitate therapy in the
future. Previous theories focused on children of narcissists being narcissistic
as well, while Dr Shaw digs deeper to find what makes some children
narcissistic and others depressed.
Dr Shaw does not limit his
views only to parents and children. He explains how narcissistic relationships
can be created in cults, within a couple, and in a psychoanalyst’s office.
Because it is possible to come across narcissistic relationships in many parts
of one’s life, particularly if it is a parent or a significant other, Dr Shaw
suggests how to not become a victim of traumatic narcissists. He first begins
this chapter with subsections on different emotions û hate, forgiveness, and
indifference û for an example of how to deal with these emotions as one feels
them. Traumatic Narcissism: Relational Systems of Subjugation is meant for both
those who are victims of narcissists and for clinicians working with
narcissists and victims.
Shaw, Daniel (2014). Traumatic Narcissism:
Relational Systems of Subjugation.
New York, NY: Routledge.
ISBN: 978-0-415-51024-0.
Paperback: 167 pages.
Includes bibliographical references
Key words: narcissism, psychotherapy,
intersubjectivity
Tweedy,
Roderick (2012). The God of the Left
Hemisphere: Blake, Bolte Taylor, and the Myth of Creation.
Reviewed
by: Tina R. Lee, New York University
In The
God of the Left Hemisphere, Roderick Tweedy explores the remarkable
connections between the activities and functions of the human brain that poet
William Blake termed ‘Urizen’ (based on the mythology in which the entity
Urizen is the embodiment of conventional law and reason), and the powerful
complex of sequencing processes which modern neuroscience identifies as left
hemisphere brain activity. Tweedy discusses these topics in connection with
neuro-anatomist Jill Bolte Taylor’s ‘Stroke of Insight’ - a TED talk and
publication recounting her experience of a stroke following a major haemorrhage
in the left side of her brain. The discussion of Blake’s responses to religion,
to reason, and to language offer rich insight and reinterpretation of the
psychological basis of the entity often referred to as ‘God’.
The book is neatly divided into two
parts, which are further divided into sub-topics. Part one, titled ‘The
Looking-Glass,’ focuses on the nature and functions of the left hemisphere.
Part two, titled ‘Down the Rabbit Hole,’ contextualizes and places the left
hemisphere in the bigger picture. Tweedy elaborates more deeply in the second
part, which also provides an examination of the main themes in the first part.
The book is layered with Blake’s poetry and Tweedy’s interpretation of it. One
underlying theme, Tweedy notes, is that we all participate in, benefit from,
and contribute to an extended social identity which we help to develop and
reflect. In addition, ordinary conversation plays a valuable and fundamental
part in this identity.
An interesting chapter, titled ‘Twilight
of the Psychopaths’ discusses the "free-wheeling left hemisphere". This, Tweedy
argues, leads to a subhuman aspect to divided rationality. He explains that the
more purely rational Reason becomes, the more its manipulative and calculating
nature emerges and is manifest. Furthermore, research into contemporary
left-hemispheric brain processes and disorders reveals the subtle ways in which
this aspect of a disengaged left hemisphere resembles the psychological state
known as schizophrenia. Tweedy notes that Blake was highly critical of
contemporary forms of rationality because of what he considered to be its
increasingly dissociated and pathological nature. One of his main arguments is
that beneath the rational processes and values, there is a form of actual
insanity.
According to Tweedy, entering the 'now' is
the immensely simple but unfamiliar experience that Blake’s poetry both
encourages and evokes. The figure of Urizen plays a crucial role in this
process since it is Urizenic thought that currently keeps man trapped in the
matrix of linearity, goals, wants, judgments, and, above all, suffering. Blake
believed that on the level of being, everything is correlated and interwoven,
and that all being is ultimately divine. To rewrite our own neurological and
bodily processes is to rewrite and modify God, according to Blake. In Tweedy’s
interpretation of Blake’s works, Tweedy states that recognizing humanity’s
divinity is not an attribute, it is a mode of perception, and it is our duty to
unleash it.
Tweedy, Roderick (2012). The God of the Left
Hemisphere: Blake, Bolte Taylor, and the Myth of Creation.
London:
Karnac Books Ltd.
ISBN: 978-1-78049-101-1.
Paperback: 332 pages.
Includes appendices and bibliography
references.
Key words: left hemisphere, William
Blake, Jill Bolte Taylor, Urizen, God, rationalizing
Wachtel, Paul L. (2011). Inside the
Session: What Really Happens in Psychotherapy.
Reviewed by: Nataliya Rubinchik, Hunter
College
Published psychology works often
give unrealistic expectations to reader. By providing successful examples from
therapies to teach the reader something, authors can unknowingly deceive even
experienced readers. Dr Paul Wachtel provides a solution for students and
clinicians alike. By publishing a book with three complete therapy sessions
written verbatim with his complete commentary, Dr Wachtel gives readers a fair
and accurate account of just what goes on inside the session and opens the door
for true understanding.
He
explains that case studies and examples provided in texts usually do not
accurately describe the anxiety a therapist might feel at not saying something
he or she might have, or the loss at which they sometimes feel when there seems
to be no breakthrough in sight. These are daily companions of every clinician,
but most seem to hide them out of view when retelling their experiences. There
is no ulterior motive to leaving out anxiety and unsuccessful treatments; they
just have no place in textbooks, theses, and published papers.
With this in mind, Dr Wachtel
works to break down three of his therapy sessions for his readers as accurately
as he can. He incorporates psychoanalytic, cognitive-behavioral, systematic,
and experiential approaches in his sessions. His goal is to give readers an
accurate account of what he calls the ‘whole arc’ of therapy sessions. ‘The
moments of feeling unclear, frustrated, even incompetent, and the moments when
the skies clear and the direction in which to move becomes apparent.
The book is organized into
three sections. The first section provides background research on psychotherapy
and its factors and expectations. The second section is the full transcription
of three separate therapy sessions, two with the one patient and one with a
different patient. The third section contains reflections on the sessions and
what they might say about Dr Wachtel. The first and third sections are
organized by chapters and subsections, outlining exactly what Dr Wachtel is
attempting to relay to his readers.
Dr Wachtel dedicates chapters
to the two aspects of therapy he finds most important: the role of anxiety and
what it could mean for various patients and treatments, and the two-person
perspective theory which suggests that what happens inside therapy is a result
of the interaction between the client and the clinician. Dr Wachtel explains
the research on both topics in a language comprehensible to students.
The
three sessions Dr Wachtel writes about in his book were filmed for an American
Psychology Association psychotherapy video series to be used as a teaching
device. This meant that the sessions were being recorded in real time with no
means of calling ‘cut.’ Even if Dr Wachtel realized he made a mistake, he would
be able to do nothing about it, just as in real therapy. He admits from the
very start that this made him anxious. He explains that it’s easy to make a
mistake in a relationship, it is easy to rupture a fragile connection, but it
takes experience and sensitivity to fix the wound and let it heal and pass
over.
Dr
Wachtel interweaves the therapy sessions he is presenting with the thoughts he
had at the exact moments he had them. He separates them by a row of asterisks
to allow readers the option of reading his comments immediately or forming
their own opinions and coming back to the comments at the end. Dr Wachtel chose
to include his commentary with the therapy primarily to show, as the teaching
tool this book is meant to be, exactly how a therapist’s mind works while he or
she is in session. Textbook examples disregard this as well, choosing to write
their final, polished thoughts at the end of the session when everything feels
like it adds up. Real life therapy, however, doesn’t work that way. And real
life therapy is exactly what Dr Wachtel is working to relay to his readers.
Wachtel, Paul L. (2011). Inside the
Session: What Really Happens in Psychotherapy.
Washington, DC: American Psychological
Association.
ISBN: 978-1-4338-0940-8.
Paperback: 283 pages.
Includes bibliographical references
Key words: psychotherapy, guide, therapy
sessions, American Psychology Association